Crest Animation Studios Ltd: Buy
CMP: Rs.16.85
Introduction:
Crest Animation is a full-service studio specializing in the
development and production of digital animated properties for
theatrical, television, home entertainment and interactive distribution
for the global entertainment industry. Crest is the undisputed leader in
the Indian animation industry, and one of the leading CGI animation
studios in the world.
Crest
Animation leverages its India advantages of highly-skilled talent and
cost efficiencies, and the creativity of its Los Angeles arm to provide
high quality CGI (computer generated imaging) animation product to the
global animation industry. Through the Crest Advantage of
Time-Cost-Quality, Crest has become a revenue differentiating player in
the global animation industry.
Crest's
state-of-the-art technology and world-class facilities, together with
its depth and breadth of experience, has earned it an unparalleled
reputation in global animation circles. Crest has delivered more than
200 half hours of television and home video titles in CGI animation,
working for such clients as Mike Young Productions, Mark Brown, Classic
Media, Nelvana, American Greetings, Marathon and Nickelodeon. Crest has
produced animation for several international TV shows such as 'Jakers!'
and 'Pet Alien' that have won many awards including Daytime EMMY, BAFTA,
FICCI Frames 2005, Humanitas Prize for Children’s Animation, and a
nomination for Annie Award.
Crest
recently tied up with Lions Gate Family Entertainment to co-produce
three movies. Crest has delivered its first feature film co-produced by
Lionsgate USA. Alpha & Omega has been accepted for consideration in
the Animated Feature Film category for the 83rd Academy Awards. It is
the first animated film from India to appear on Oscar's list."
Financials:
For FY12, the net loss of the company came down to Rs.20.56 Cr to
Rs.171.15 Cr in the same period previous year. For Q2FY13, the company
came out with a net profit of Rs.26 lakhs as against a loss of Rs.3.17
Cr in the same period previous year. In terms of sequential values too,
the company did well. The net loss of the company for Q1FY13, came out
to be Rs.32 lakhs as against a net profit of Rs.26 lakhs in Q2FY13.
Also, both on Q-o-Q and sequential basis, its OPM and NPMs increased
substantially. This points towards a turnaround of the company.
Triggers:
(i) As
on September 30, 2012, the company has invested Rs.74,464,890 in Norm
LLC, a special purpose vehicle which is formed for the purpose of
feature film Norm of the North. For Norm Financing LLC the company also
has outstanding receivables of Rs.74,620,398, unbilled revenue of
Rs.169,639,437 & Work in process of Rs. 60,247,558. In addition,
Company has an Investment of Rs.1380.23 lacs in a subsidiary Company
which has receivable as at March 31, 2012 of Rs. 1114.22 lacs due from
norm Financing LLC. Work on this project was
deferred during first quarter of Annual year 2011-12 due to the
uncertainty prevailing on the financing arrangements of the same.
However, based on discussions with alternate financier, the Company is
confident of resumption of the project and has recommenced work on the
same. A work-in-process of Rs.14,377,025 has been booked for the quarter
ended September 30, 2012. There are some rumours that this work has
actually started. In view of the intended recourse
of the legal proceedings against the defaulted financier and
developments for the alternate financier, the management is of the view
that there is no diminution in the value of these investments,
receivables & work in progress. These are considered to be
recoverable and therefore no provision considered is necessary.
(ii) The
company's operations are primarily funded from debtors realization,
borrowings from private parties and promoters. Management has renewed /
rescheduled its credit facilities with the banks and other private
parties which are now falling due between the period from October, 2012
to July 2014. Management is confident of renewing
the loans from banks and private parties on their due date. Further,
management is in discussions with prospective Investors to raise funds
from the liquidation of shares held by the CAS Benefit Trust (Treasury
stock”) to meet its working capital requirements.
(iii)
The Company continues to execute work on major hire projects.
Considering the above and based on a detailed plan for meeting its cash
flow requirements for the next 12 months prepared by management and
approved by the Board of Directors, the company, despite the possible
material uncertainty in this regard is confident of meeting its
obligations as and when they fall due.
(iv) The
Company has long-term Investments of Rs.7,140,500 in a joint SPV which
is having film properties under development for more than 3 years.
Pending the final outcome of the decision to be taken by the joint SPV
partner on the development of the film properties held by the investee.
Management is of the view that there is no permanent diminution in the
value of this long term-Investment.
(v) The
Company continued work on the second feature film “Norm of the North”
despite lack of financial closure, inviting qualification from the
auditors. Alternate financing arrangements which the Company hoped to
finalize this year were not successful in the period. The Company is
working on financial closure in the coming 2-3 months.
(vi) The Company has taken Television contracts for execution like
Brown Bag, Gloe, Swan Princess-5 after the successful completion
and
fine delivery of Swan Princess-4. Alpha & Omega, co-produced by the
Company along with Lions Gate performed reasonably well with gross box
office collection over US$ 50 million and sale of direct to video’s and
television rights raising more than US$ 22 million in FY12. over US$ 50
million and sale of direct to video’s and television rights raising more
than US$ 22 million.
(vii)
The management believes that the worst seems to be well behind. The
first quarter of 2012-13 has shown results on the work put in by the
Company on different DVD/Television contracts, as the collections have
been robust enough to take care of ongoing operational requirements as
well retiring small portion of short term borrowings.
(viii)
Continued negotiations and discussions are on for new contracts as well
as for new Joint Venture initiatives for ensuring a robust and
predictable future pipeline and guaranteed work for hire services.
(ix)
The Direct to Video sales of “The Little Engine that Could”, coproduced
by the Company with Universal Studios, are in line with their
expectations and during the year, FY12, the US subsidiary received a
total of US$ 300,000 from Universal Studios towards the subsidiary’s
share. In line with the accounting practice followed by the US
subsidiary, this amount has gone towards reducing the carrying value of
the inventory.
(x)
The Company’s information technology division known as “STG” i.e System
and Technical Group which has been innovating and deploying technology
successfully since past few years through
various means like
high-performance storage, workflow and asset management tools, grid
computing based render farm etc. These deployments have enhanced project
delivery capabilities removed bottle necks related to transfer of files
and approval delays. Currently the Company is working on
next-generation computing based on “Hardware Accelerators” for
visualization and computation to increase the productivity of the studio
at highest level. Crest is the only studio in the Asia-Pacific region
working on such technologies to enhance the performance of studio.
(xi) The Company has adequate positive net worth remaining after
adjusting losses and has not witnessed the loss of any of its critical clients nor the stoppage of work from them.
(xii) By Virtue of Amalgamation which came in to effect 26 July, 2011, the following downstream subsidiaries have become direct
subsidiaries now.
1. Crest Animation Inc. (CAI)
2. Crest Animation Productions Inc.(CAP)
3. Roop BDR Productions Inc. (RBP)
During
the year FY12, the company entered into television contract with
Moonscoop LLC for producing 13 episodes of 11 minutes each titled
"Gloe". The company took television contract for Ireland based studio
Brown Bag Films Ltd, for producing 52 episodes of television series
titled "Octonauts".
(xiii) The
company has successfully completed and delivered DVD project Swan
princess 4 for Sony pictures. Due to success of fourth series of Swan
Princess, the company has bagged the contract for the fifth series of
Swan Princess.
(xiv)
During the year, FY2, the company entered into agreement with
Snapdragon Inc for producing televised version of the movie "How to
train you Dragon". The company started work on the project
simultaneously along with the other projects which the company executed.
However, due to technical complexities, the company had to terminate
the contract in order to concentrate on the delivery of other projects.
But the things are expected to be streamlined in the Q3FY13.(xv)
The company continued to work on the second feature film "Norm of the
North" which is a part of Lionsgate deal. However, one of the financiers
to this project defaulted their obligation to fund due to financial
crisis in their region. The company is reviewing intended legal recourse
to be initiated against the financier. Alternate financing
arrangements are also under negotiation.
(xvi)
The company continued to work on "Ribbit", another CGI feature for
limited release which the company is co-producing with KRU Capital Sdn.
Bhd, Malaysia.
Concerns:
(i)
There have been delays and salaries to employees are outstanding.
However, this has not impacted execution of work and in the past three
months the Company has in fact, recruited additional artists to serve
new contracts. The Company is not in default with respect to statutory
dues and obligations except Tax deducted at source which have all since
been paid with delays.
(ii) The Company has accumulated losses of Rs.
30.72 Cr as at September 30, 2012. However, the company is confident to
cover up this loss within a short time, as the business is picking up.
Despite the overall negative sentiments prevailing in the business
environment the Company was able to place a small portion of the
treasury shares and is confident of completing additional placements in
future.
Conclusion:
Considering the points mentioned above, the investors can buy the scrip
of Crest Animation Studios Ltd, a turnaround story, at Rs.16.85, for a
target of Rs.27--29--32-37-41, in the coming days.
Note: This report was posted on the blog: SumanSpeaks, on 8th January, 2013.